Penny

Da Stardew Valley Wiki.
Penny
Penny.png
Informazione
Compleanno: Fall.png Autunno 2
Vive a: Pelican Town
Indirizzo: Roulotte
Famiglia:

Pam Icon.png Pam (Madre)

Amici:

Sam Icon.png Sam

Matrimonio:
Migliori regali: Diamond.png DiamanteMelon.png MelonePoppyseed Muffin.png Muffin ai semi di papaveroPoppy.png PapaveroSandfish.png Pesce delle sabbieRoots Platter.png Piatto 'radicale'Red Plate.png Piatto rossoEmerald.png SmeraldoTom Kha Soup.png Tom Kha Gai
Robin building.png
“Ho ancora molto lavoro da fare”
— Robin

Traduzione incompleta

Questo articolo o sezione non è stato completamente tradotto in italiano. Siete invitati a collaborare alla sua traduzione modificandola.
Ultima modifica di Margotbean del 2019-08-09 20:46:25.

“Penny lives with her mom, Pam, in a little trailer by the river. While Pam is out carousing at the saloon, Penny quietly tends to her chores in the dim, stuffy room she is forced to call home. She is shy and modest, without any grand ambitions for life other than settling in and starting a family. She likes to cook (although her skills are questionable) and read books from the local library.”
Dev Update #12

Penny is a villager who lives in Pelican Town. She's one of the twelve characters available to marry. Her trailer is just east of the center of town, west of the river.

Schedule

Penny can usually be found in town reading or cleaning up at the trailer she shares with Pam. On Tuesday, Wednesday, and Friday she tutors Jas and Vincent at the museum, walking them both home afterwards. She doesn't tutor in the Summer season. Many Saturdays in Spring and Fall she'll take them to the town playground.

On the 4th of Winter, she has an appointment at the clinic.

When it's raining Penny can either be found inside her trailer or visiting the museum looking at the selection of books.

Spring.png Primavera

Monday, Thursday, Sunday

Time Location
8:10 AM Leaves her trailer and goes outside to read near the town graveyard.

Penny location 0.jpg

12:30 PM Returns to the trailer to wash dishes.
4:00 PM Leaves the trailer again to go outside the saloon where she sits on a bench with Maru.

Penny location 1.jpg

6:40 PM Returns to her trailer for the evening.

Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday

Time Location
9:00 AM Leaves her trailer and goes to the museum/library. Jas and Vincent join her there.
2:00 PM Leaves the library and stands near the Ice Cream Stand watching over Jas and Vincent.
4:20 PM Continues to Vincent's house and says goodbye.
5:50 PM Walks Jas the rest of the way home and says goodbye.
6:30 PM Returns to her trailer for the evening.


Saturday

Time Location
9:00 AM In her room.
10:00 AM Leaves her trailer to meet up with Jas and Vincent near the town graveyard.
12:00 PM Walks Jas and Vincent to the playground north of the plaza and watches them play.
5:00 PM Walks Jas and Vincent back to town and drops them off in front of Emily and Haley's house.
6:30 PM Returns to her trailer for the evening.
Summer.png Estate

Regular Schedule

Time Location
8:10 AM Wakes up and walks through town to stand by the river behind JojaMart.
1:00 PM Walks back through town and sits down next to the community center.
6:00 PM Leaves town and returns to the trailer to do dishes.
8:00 PM Goes to bed in her room in the trailer for the evening.

Sunny Weather

Time Location
8:00 AM Leaves her trailer and walks into town.
12:00 PM Goes up to Carpenter's Shop and sits inside.
6:00 PM Leaves Carpenter's Shop and returns to the trailer to do dishes.
9:00 PM Goes to bed in her room in the trailer for the evening.

Monday (Sunny weather)

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up and walks through town to stand by the river behind JojaMart.
9:30 AM Watching the river behind JojaMart.
1:00 PM Walks back through town and to the community center.
2:30 PM Sitting on a bench to the right of the community center.
6:00 PM Leaves town and returns to the trailer.
7:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Tuesday (Sunny Weather)

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up for the day, leaves her trailer and goes outside near the town graveyard.
9:00 AM Reading a book under a tree near the town graveyard.
12:30 PM Returns to the trailer.
4:00 PM Leaves the trailer again to go outside the saloon where she sits on a bench.
6:30 PM Leaves town and returns to the trailer.
7:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Wednesday (Sunny Weather)

Time Location
9:00 AM Leaves the trailer and walks to the Museum.
10:00 AM In the Museum.
2:00 PM Pelican Town, outside of the Museum near bridge.
4:00 PM Outside 2 Willow Lane, walking Vincent and Jas home.
6:30 PM Leaves Marnie's Ranch and returns to home for the evening.
8:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Thursday (Sunny Weather)

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up and walks through town to stand by the river behind JojaMart.
9:30 PM Watching the river behind JojaMart.
1:00 PM Walks back through town and to the community center.
2:30 PM Sitting to right of the community center.
6:00 PM Leaves town and returns to the trailer.
7:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Friday (Sunny Weather)

Time Location
9:00 AM Leaves the trailer and walks to the Museum.
10:00 AM In the Museum.
2:00 PM Outside of the Museum near bridge.
4:00 PM Outside 2 Willow Lane, Walking Vincent and Jas home.
6:30 PM Leaves Marnie's Ranch and returns to home for the evening.
8:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Saturday (Sunny Weather)

Time Location
10:00 AM Leaves her trailer and goes outside near the town graveyard.
11:00 AM With the kids near the town graveyard.
12:00 PM Walk kids to the playground, left of the community center.
1:00 PM At the playground, play with kids.
5:00 PM Walks Jas and Vincent to Emily's house.
6:00 PM Beside Emily's house, talking with Jas and Vincent.
8:00 PM Goes to the trailer.
9:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Sunday (Sunny Weather)

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up and walks through town to stand by the river behind JojaMart.
9:30 PM Watching the river behind JojaMart.
1:00 PM Walks back through town and to the community center.
2:30 PM Sitting to right of the community center.
6:00 PM Leaves town and returns to the trailer.
7:00 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.
Fall.png Autunno

Sunday, Monday, Thursday

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up for the day, leaves her trailer and goes outside to read near the town graveyard.

Penny location 0.jpg

12:30 PM Returns to the trailer to wash dishes.
4:00 PM Leaves the trailer again to go outside The Stardrop Saloon where she sits on a bench, with Maru on Sundays and Mondays, alone on Thursdays.

Penny location 1.jpg

6:40 PM Returns to her trailer for the evening.
7:20 PM Goes to bed.

Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday

Time Location
9:00 AM Leaves the trailer and walks to the Museum.
10:00 AM In the Museum. Vincent joins her at 10:30 AM, Jas at 11:00 AM.
2:00 PM Goes outside the Museum, near the river, at the bridge.
4:20 PM Leaves for 2 Willow Lane, walking Vincent and Jas home. Pauses there.
5:40 PM Continues to Marnie's Ranch, walking Jas home for the evening.
6:30 PM Leaves Jas at Marnie's Ranch and returns to home for the evening.
8:00 PM Arrives at the trailer, then goes to bed.

Saturday

Time Location
10:00 AM Gets out of bed.
11:00 AM Meets Jas and Vincent at the tree where she often reads, near the town graveyard.
12:00 PM All three leave for the playground.
1:00 PM At the playground with Jas and Vincent
5:00 PM Leaves the playground and walks to Emily's house with Jas and Vincent
6:20 PM Arrives outside Emily's house
8:00 PM Jas and Vincent head for home, while Penny goes home to the trailer.
8:40 PM Arrives at the trailer and goes to bed.
Winter.png Inverno

Regular Schedule

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up for the day, leaves her trailer and goes outside to read near the town graveyard.

Penny location 0.jpg

12:30 PM Returns to the trailer to wash dishes.
4:00 PM Leaves the trailer again to go outside the saloon where she sits on a bench with Maru.

Penny location 1.jpg

6:40 PM Returns to her trailer for the evening.

Wednesday, Friday

Time Location
9:00 AM Leaves the trailer and walks to the Museum.
10:00 AM In the Museum. Vincent joins her at 10:30 AM, Jas at 11:00 AM.
2:00 PM Goes outside the Museum, near the river, at the bridge.
4:20 PM Leaves for 2 Willow Lane, walking Vincent and Jas home. Pauses there.
5:40 PM Continues to Marnie's Ranch, walking Jas home for the evening.
6:30 PM Leaves Jas at Marnie's Ranch and returns to home for the evening.
8:00 PM Arrives at the trailer, then goes to bed.


Saturday

Time Location
2:30 PM At the playground with Jas and Vincent.
5:00 PM Walks Jas and Vincent to Emily's house.
6:20 PM Beside Emily's house, talking with Jas and Vincent.
8:00 PM Goes to the trailer with Jas.
8:10 PM Arrives at the trailer for the evening.

Winter (Community Center Restored)

Time Location
9:00 AM Wakes up and moves around her trailer.
10:30 AM Leaves her trailer and walks to the community center to read.
3:00 PM Continues moving around the community center.
6:00 PM Leaves the community center and returns to the trailer to do dishes.
9:00 PM Goes to bed in her room in the trailer for the evening.

Winter 4th

Time Location
9:00 AM Wakes up and moves around her trailer. "I have an appointment at the clinic this afternoon."
11:30 AM Walks from her trailer to Harvey's Clinic for her annual checkup.
1:30 PM Continues getting checkup at clinic. "Hey! A little privacy, please?"
4:00 PM Leaves clinic and goes to sit in town.
7:00 PM Leaves town and returns to the trailer to do dishes.
9:00 PM Goes to bed in her room in the trailer for the evening.
Deviazioni
Her schedule can deviate if there are specific conditions like season, weather, or certain days of the week. Below are her schedule deviations prioritized highest to lowest (for example when it rains that schedule will override all others below it)

Raining on Day 23

Time Location
8:00 AM Wakes up and leaves trailer.
8:50 AM Sits under tree in town, west of the graveyard.

Penny location 0.jpg

12:30 PM Returns from town to the trailer and does some dishes.
4:00 PM Leaves trailer for town again.
4:30 PM Sits on bench south of the Saloon.
6:40 PM Returns to the trailer to go to bed in her room for the evening.

Day 9 & Day 23 (With less than 6 hearts with Sam)

Time Location
9:00 AM Wakes up and walks around her trailer.
11:00 AM Walks from the trailer out to town and sits.

Penny location 0.jpg

4:00 PM Returns from town to the trailer and does some dishes.
6:30 PM Goes to bed in her room in the trailer for the evening.

Raining (Alternative A)

Time Location
9:00 AM Trailer is unlocked. Penny is in her bedroom.
11:00 AM Moves to the kitchen.
1:00 PM Does some dishes.
3:00 PM Sits on the couch, probably watching TV.
6:00 PM Returns to her bedroom, reading by the bookshelf.
9:00 PM Goes to bed for the evening.

Raining (Alternative B)

Time Location
8:20 AM Leaves the trailer and walks to the Museum to sit outside. "I'm going to go inside, I just wanted a quiet moment."
12:00 PM Goes inside the Museum to look at the bookshelves.
4:00 PM Leaves the Museum and returns to the trailer to watch some television.
7:00 PM Moves over to the sink in the trailer to do some dishes.
9:00 PM Goes to bed for the evening.
Mermaid's Pendant.png Matrimonio

Monday

Time Location
8:30 AM Leaves the farmhouse and heads to Pierre's General Store.
11:30 AM Leaves Pierre's. In town, reading.
4:00 PM Sitting in town.
6:10 PM Leaves town to return home to the farm.
10:00 PM Goes to bed

Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday

Time Location
8:30 AM Leaves the the farm and walks to the Museum. "Hi, honey. It's nice of you to visit me at work."
2:00 PM Leaves the Museum and walks with Vincent and Jas to town.
4:20 PM In front of Haley and Emily's house while walking Vincent and Jas home.
5:50 PM Walks Jas home to Marnie's Ranch in the woods west of town.
6:30 PM Leaves Marnie's Ranch and returns to home for the evening.
10:00 PM Goes to bed

Thursday, Saturday, Sunday

Remains at the farm all day. Goes to bed at 10:00 PM.

Relationships

Penny lives with her mother Pam. She's friends with Sam.

She also teaches the local children, Jas and Vincent, at the museum a few days a week and accompanies them to the playground sometimes.

During the eight-heart cutscene, Vincent remarks that he once saw Sam and Penny climbing trees, at which Penny becomes visibly startled and scolds Vincent for gossiping. ConcernedApe has explained that he "wasn't trying to imply anything serious" with the scene regarding a continuation of Penny's interest in Sam. "[A]t 8 hearts...she's not actually interested in Sam anymore."[1]

Gifts

Articolo principale: Amicizia
Vedi anche: Elenco di tutti i regali

You can give Penny up to two gifts per week (plus one on her birthday), which will raise or lower her friendship with you. Gifts on her birthday (Fall 2) will have 8× effect and show a unique dialogue.
For loved or liked gifts, Penny will say

“Un regalo di compleanno? Molto gentile da parte tua! Lo adoro.”
“Ti ricordavi del mio compleanno! Grazie. È magnifico.”

For neutral gifts, Penny will say

“Oh, un regalo di compleanno! Grazie.”

For disliked or hated gifts, Penny will say

“Oh... È per il mio compleanno? ... Grazie.”

Love

“Grazie! Mi piace tantissimo!”
Image Name Description Source Ingredients
Penny Happy.png
Diamond.png
Diamond Una gemma rara e preziosa. Mining
Emerald.png
Emerald Una pietra preziosa dal colore verde splendente. Mining
Melon.png
Melon Un frutto estivo fresco e dolce. Farming - Summer
Poppy.png
Poppy In aggiunta al suo fiore colorato, il papavero ha vari usi culinari e medicinali. Farming - Summer
Poppyseed Muffin.png
Poppyseed Muffin Ha un effetto calmante. Cooking Poppy.png Papavero (1)Wheat Flour.png Farina di grano (1)Sugar.png Zucchero (1)
Red Plate.png
Red Plate Ricco di antiossidanti. Cooking Red Cabbage.png Cavolo rosso (1)Radish.png Ravanello (1)
Roots Platter.png
Roots Platter Ti darà la voglia di dissotterrarne ancora. Cooking Cave Carrot.png Carota di grotta (1)Winter Root.png Radice invernale (1)
Sandfish.png
Sandfish Prova a nascondersi camuffandosi. Fishing
Tom Kha Soup.png
Tom Kha Soup Che sapori incredibili! Cooking Coconut.png Noce di cocco (1)Shrimp.png Gamberetto (1)Common Mushroom.png Fungo comune (1)

Like

“Grazie! Sembra speciale.”
Image Name Description Source
Penny.png
Dandelion.png
Dandelion Non avrà il più bello dei fiori, ma le foglie sono ottime per l'insalata. Foraging - Spring
Leek.png
Leek Saporito parente della cipolla. Foraging - Spring

Neutral

“Grazie, sembra grazioso.”
Image Name Description Source
Penny Neutral.png
Chanterelle.png
Chanterelle Un fungo saporito dall'odore fruttato e dal sapore leggermente pepato. Foraging - Fall
Common Mushroom.png
Common Mushroom Ha un leggero gusto di noce, e un buona consistenza. Foraging - Fall
Daffodil.png
Daffodil Un tipico fiore primaverile che può fungere da bel regalo. Foraging - Spring
Hazelnut.png
Hazelnut Alla faccia della nocciola! Foraging - Fall
Morel.png
Morel Ricercata per il suo peculiare sapore di noce. Foraging - Fall
Snow Yam.png
Snow Yam Questa piccolina si nascondeva sotto la neve. Foraging - Winter
Wild Horseradish.png
Wild Horseradish Una radice piccante che cresce in primavera. Foraging - Spring
Winter Root.png
Winter Root Un tubero amidoso. Foraging - Winter

*Note that Dinosaur Eggs are considered Artifacts and not Eggs for gifting purposes.

Dislike

“Ah, è per me? ...grazie.”
Image Name Description Source Ingredients
Penny Concerned.png
Algae Soup.png
Algae Soup È un tantino viscida. Cooking Green Algae.png Alghetta verde (4)
Duck Feather.png
Duck Feather È così colorata. Ducks
Pale Broth.png
Pale Broth Un brodo delicato con una punta di zolfo. Cooking White Algae.png Alghetta bianca (2)
Purple Mushroom.png
Purple Mushroom Un fungo raro che si trova nelle profondità delle caverne. Foraging - The Mines
Quartz.png
Quartz Un cristallo chiaro comunemente trovato in caverne e miniere. Foraging - Mines
Red Mushroom.png
Red Mushroom Un fungo maculato che a volte si trova nelle caverne. Foraging
Salmonberry.png
Salmonberry Una bacca primaverile col sapore della foresta. Foraging - Spring
Wool.png
Wool Lana morbida e batuffolosa. Rabbits, Sheep

Hate

“Ugh... Scusa, ma la detesto di cuore, questa cosa.”
Image Name Description Source Ingredients
Penny Annoyed.png
Beer.png
Beer Bevi con moderazione. Keg
The Stardrop Saloon
Wheat.png Grano (1)
Grape.png
Grape Un dolce frutto a grappolo. Farming, Foraging
Holly.png
Holly Le foglie e il rosso acceso delle bacche sono una diffusa decorazione invernale. Foraging - Winter
Hops.png
Hops Un fiore amaro e pungente, usato per aromatizzare la birra. Farming
Mead.png
Mead Una bevanda fermentata dal miele. Bevi con moderazione. Keg Honey.png Miele (1)
Pale Ale.png
Pale Ale Bevi con moderazione. Keg Hops.png Luppolo (1)
Rabbit's Foot.png
Rabbit's Foot Dicono che porti fortuna. Rabbits
Wine.png
Wine Bevi con moderazione. Keg Any Fruit (1)

Heart Events

Two Hearts

Two Hearts.png

Enter Pelican Town on a sunny day between 9am and 2pm.

Dettagli 
George looks into his mailbox and wonders how he'll reach a letter in the back. Penny notices and gets the letter out for him. George is upset at being seen helpless and scolds her. Penny sees you and asks if you were watching them.
  • "I was. You did a kind thing there, Penny." (+50 amicizia.) Penny thanks you, but is unhappy that George was upset.
  • "You should've left him alone. Now he's grumpy." (-50 amicizia.) Penny apologises to George.
  • "I'm just taking a walk, minding my own business." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) Penny responds "I see".

Regardless of your choice, George sighs and apologises to Penny for getting angry. He says it was very kind of her to help. Penny says she understands. After George leaves, Penny says it must be difficult growing old.

  • "I'd rather not think about it." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "I guess you're right... why stress out about something you can't change?"
  • "It's just a different part of life." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "You're right, we shouldn't ignore the reality of aging. I guess the sooner we come to terms with our mortality, the more time we can spend really living in the here-and-now."
  • "That's why we should respect our elders." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "That's nice of you to say... I totally agree with you. We should treat our elders with the same respect we hope to receive ourselves some day."
  • "I'd rather die young..." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "That's a horrible thing to say. Life is a precious thing to waste like that!"

Penny bids you farewell and leaves.

Four Hearts

Four Hearts.png

Enter the trailer when she's home.

Dettagli 
Penny complains about how messy the place is, and asks if you could help her clean up. As you do so, Pam returns home and yells at Penny for letting someone else clean her home. Pam eventually asks you to leave, and they continue their discussion privately. Pam admits that she's embarrassed to have strangers clean up the house. The next day, you get a letter of apology from Penny.

Note that this event will not trigger if the player has purchased the Community Upgrade.

Six Hearts

Six Hearts.png

Enter the trailer when she's home.

Dettagli 
Penny asks you to try a recipe she invented.
  • "(Lie) Mmm! That was delicious!" (+50 amicizia.) She responds: "You really mean it? Thank you! ... it's such a relief to hear that. I've been working so hard on this recipe, and I'm really proud of it. Hey, since you're the first person to try it, I'm going to name this one 'Chili de <your name>'."
  • "Uh... can I get the rest to go?" (-50 amicizia.) Penny is crestfallen and says her recipe was a failure.
  • "Well it's definitely unique... how did you get it so rubbery?" (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) Penny is crestfallen and says her recipe was a failure.

Regardless of your choice, she invites you to watch a movie together and your energy is increased by 165.

Note that this event will not trigger if the player has purchased the Community Upgrade.

Eight Hearts

Eight Hearts.png

Enter Cindersap Forest between 9am and 4pm.

Dettagli 
Penny is on a field trip with Jas and Vincent. Penny asks you if you'd like to be a guest speaker and share your experience about the countryside with the children.
  • "I'd love to!" (+10 amicizia.) She responds, "Great! Let me just call the children over."
  • "Sure." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "Great! Let me just call the children over."
  • "No... I can't stand kids." (-1500 amicizia.) She responds, "Really?... Uh... Well, alright. I guess I'll see you later then." The scene ends.

If you agree to speak to the kids, you're prompted for a number of dialogue options (which have no effect on friendship). Afterwards Penny tells the children to run along and asks you if you'd like to be a parent.

  • "I haven't really thought about it." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "Oh no? Well, I guess that makes sense... you're busy with other things right now."
  • "Absolutely. I want a big family." (+20 amicizia.) She responds, "... Me too. I'm glad you feel that way."
  • "I guess so. It's a natural urge." (+20 amicizia.) She responds, "Yes... the urge to care for something innocent and helpless. It makes sense that we'd feel that."
  • "No, I don't think I'd be good at it." (+10 amicizia.) She responds, "Oh, really? I think you'd make a good parent."
  • "No, The world's crowded enough already." (-10 amicizia.) She responds, "hmm... If everyone thought like that, humans would die out."
  • "No, I don't want to be tied down with a family." (-10 amicizia.) She responds, "Oh... That's kind of sad... but I guess I can understand your point."

The scene fades and she thanks you for showing up.

Ten Hearts

Ten Hearts.png

You receive a letter from Penny. After receiving the letter, enter the pool area of the spa between 7pm and midnight.

Dettagli 
Penny joins you in the pool. She asks if you know why she invited you here.
  • "You have something to tell me." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "That's right..."
  • "I'm not exactly sure." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "Really? I thought you'd have noticed by now..."
  • "You wanted to see me in my bathing suit." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.) She responds, "No!"

Penny confesses her feelings for you.

  • "I feel the same way about you." (Nessun effetto sull'amicizia.)
    • If the player is male, she responds, "...Oh, <your name>. I thought you did, but I wasn't sure. ...I'll always remember this night." You kiss and the scene ends.
    • If the player is female, she responds, "...Oh, <your name>. I thought you did, but I wasn't sure. You look so beautiful tonight... I... *gasp*" You kiss and the scene ends.
  • "Sorry, but I don't like you in that way..." (-1500 amicizia.) She bursts into tears and the scene ends.

Group Ten-Heart Event

Ten Hearts.png Bouquet

Marriage

Articolo principale: Matrimonio

Once married, Penny will move into the farmhouse. Like other marriage candidates, she will add her own room to the right of the bedroom. She'll also set up a small garden behind the farmhouse where she'll sometimes go to read. She will continue to work at the Museum and travel to town to work there on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Fridays.

On rainy mornings, Penny may offer you Large Milk, Egg, Mixed Seeds, or a Geode. On mornings when Penny stays inside all day, she may offer you Omelet, Hashbrowns, or Pancakes for breakfast. On rainy nights she may offer you dinner: Salmon Dinner, Crispy Bass, Fried Eel, Carp Surprise, or Vegetable Medley.

Quests

Portraits

Timeline

Penny's look evolved over the years the game was in development. Here's a timeline showing how ConcernedApe's art and Penny's style changed over the years before the game was launched.

Penny Timeline.png

History

  • 1.0: Introduced.
  • 1.1: Added reading garden area behind farmhouse if married.
  • 1.3: Added group 10-heart event.

References

  1. https://www.reddit.com/r/StardewValley/comments/4b8s7v/comment/d16zqdf